Who is Boro's best ever manager?

Nine days ago in the midst of 'Karankagate' we tweeted the following;

"Here's an interesting stat - Aitor Karanka's win ratio @Boro is 51.9%, Jack Charlton's was 45.6%, Bryan Robson's 40.45% & Bruce Rioch's 40%."

Our information was based on an article we'd read but nevertheless the Tweet led to the inevitable question about which divisions of the Football pyramid those statistics related to. Other than being safe in the knowledge that Aitor Karanka's stats all referred to the second tier we were unable to answer the question. However, after a good deal of research, we can now reveal who is Boro's leading manager in each of the top two tiers of English Football.

The answer is (Cue drumroll)... Jack Charlton.

The statistics that support such an assertion are thus.

Top Division	Pld	Won	% Win		2nd Tier	Pld	Won	% Win
Jack Charlton	126	47	37.30		Jack Charlton	51	30	58.82
John Neal	168	59	35.12		Bryan Robson	92	50	54.35
Steve McClaren	190	64	33.68		Gareth Southgate	13	7	53.85
Terry Venables	22	7	31.82		Aitor Karanka	119	62	52.10
Bryan Robson	168	50	29.76		Lenny Lawrence	92	41	44.57
Lenny Lawrence	42	11	26.19		Colin Todd	48	20	41.67
Gareth Southgate	114	29	25.44		Tony Mowbray	137	50	36.50
Bruce Rioch	38	9	23.68		Bruce Rioch	84	27	32.14
Bobby Murdoch	42	8	19.05		Malcolm Allison	68	20	29.41
Colin Todd	12	1	8.33		Gordon Strachan	43	12	27.91
					Willie Maddren	70	17	24.29
					Bobby Murdoch	7	0	0

These figures are for League games only, no FA Cups, League Cup, UEFA Cup, Anglo-Italian, Zenith Data Systems or pre-season friendlies are included. Nor are Bruce Rioch's 27 wins in 46 games in the Third tier of English football.

So there you have it. You may argue that there should be a qualifying number of matches before these stats count rather like cricket averages. That might then preclude Bobby Murdoch & Gareth Southgate's 2nd tier performance and Colin Todd's effort in the old first division. Whatever the case I am minded of Darrell Huff's book recommended by an old university tutor of mine many moons ago.

The title of the book...?

"How to lie with statistics".

A Hull of a Weekend

The Tigers' visit to the Riverside Stadium last Friday heralded Aitor Karanka's reincarnation as the Middlesbrough Head Coach. For us it was almost

'death by a thousand sideways passes'

Hull pressed and Boro failed to find a way forward let alone through the Tigers defence. Then out of the gloom, or more accurately the smoke from yet another incendiary device, came a moment of magic as the industrious David Nugent headed an injury time winner that sparked scenes of wild jubilation amongst the Boro faithful and indeed the not-so faithful. In spite of the three points Middlesbrough finished the weekend in third place, outside of the automatic promotion spots but with a game in hand.

As for us, on Saturday we went to Hull and back, well almost. To be precise we went to Brantingham near Brough in North Humberside to cover Darlington Mowden Park's oval ball game against the intriguingly named Hull Ionians.

For those of you who are interested, alongside the Dorians, Aeolians and the Achaeans, the Ionians were one of the four tribes of Ancient Greece. Born out of a merger between Hull East Riding and Ionians rugby clubs in June 1989, the Hull branch of Ionians' tribe ply their trade at the rather more modern and impressive Brantingham Park.

Warren Seals it with last gasp kick.
©Shutter Press

The game itself was dominated not by either side but by the referee and we mused that today

'death was to be by a thousand whistle blows.'

More enthralling than exciting Mowden won with the last play of the game, a penalty converted by Warren Seals which led to the inevitable headline of "Warren Seals it with last gasp kick".

This weekend we head north to Shielfield Park for the Scottish League Two match of the day between Berwick Rangers and Elgin City. Not to be outdone we'll be back before that with a piece on who is Boro's best ever manager...

AK OK

Last night's statement from Middlesbrough Football Club in which they confirmed

"..that Head Coach Aitor Karanka will be resuming first team duties with the club with immediate effect."

was not only a massive u turn by both parties but an unprecedented move in football. It is difficult to recall another occasion when a manager has walked out, been refused entry to the training ground and missed a game only to return to his post a few days later. What happens next remains to be seen but if Boro are to secure one of the automatic promotion spots, something needs to change. Their performances at Blackburn, Rotherham & Charlton were abject and when the Tigers roar into town on Friday there needs to be a much better and bigger commitment from all concerned.

Manager Merry-go-round

McClaren out Benitez in, Freedman out and Karanka goes AWOL or does he? The football manager merry go-round is currently at full throttle.

Newcastle's handling of their managerial affairs was nothing short of shambolic and yet throughout it all Steve McClaren behaved with the utmost professionalism. Can the same be said for Aitor Karanka? Middlesbrough's Spanish manager allegedly stormed out of a players' meeting and was absent from their 2-0 defeat at relegation threatened Charlton Athletic yesterday. His relationship with certain players is supposedly almost at breaking point and speculation suggests that Stewart Downing, a favourite of club chairman Steve Gibson is one of those players. However, after a poor run of form it would not be difficult to make a case that Downing shouldn't be in the current starting eleven

Whatever has happened at the Boro it needs resolving and resolving quickly. In a quote attributed to BBC Radio Tees sport it was reported that

"It is inconceivable that Aitor Karanka will return to manage Middlesbrough."

and yet the majority of fans want him back. Gibson is due to meet Karanka within the next 48 hours. Who will be in charge for Boro's crucial game against Hull City on Friday will no doubt be decided as a result of that meeting.